It appears I needed more than brake pads. I needed new rotors as well. They were quite warped. I wondered why the brakes felt so funny.
Additionally, I brought the Jeep in and the mechanic started talking about the New York State Inspection. My car is still registered in South Carolina, hence it doesn't need an inspection. The counter to this argument is that on Fort Drum, you need a NY state inspection. Fortunately for me, I never got rid of my Fort Bragg NC sticker, so I can basically drive through the gate at will and no one says anything to me.
While I was getting the Jeep "inspected", the mechanic, of course, tells me that everything is wrong with the Jeep and it's a miracle it's even driving down the road. I know I'm probably due for tires before the winter, but I can hold off on it for now. Nevertheless, the mechanic told me that my tires would not pass inspection, even though they probably have more tread left on them than most new street tires. And, of course, I must replace all four tires at once, lest I cause catastrophic damage to the Jeep.
I do know a little about auto maintenance, but I'm in that sophomoric phase where I think I know a lot more than I really do. Which is actually worse than knowing nothing at all. Literally, a conversation between me and a mechanic could easily go like this.
Mechanic: Ah, let me gauge this thingy here. Oh no. Now that's bad.
Me: What?
Mechanic: Well, your flux capacitor here. It's not operating at 1.21 gigawats.
Me: Ah, of course, I remember hearing about that part on like foreign cars and stuff. I didn't know I had one of those.
Mechanic: I mean, you can drive on it for a while, but once you hit 88 miles per hour.
Me: Yeah, you're probably right. I guess I should really should get that fixed...
At any rate, I continued paying for an inspection, since I can legally get away with not having it inspected, but the mechanic kept insisting.
"Just put your top up and we can gauge the visibility through the windows"
I take a look at the open-topped Jeep.
"I guess you can call that 'unobstructed 360-degree vision', if I'm not mistaken". Never mind the fact that I will be putting the hard top back on in winter, thus completely making an inspection on the windows meaningless. As long as I still have the "Fort Bragg" sticker on the Jeep, I'm still technically on the right side of the law. I think.
The focus question comes about because there were so many really bad auto maintenance places when I was at Fort Rucker in Alabama. I took my old Saturn SL2 in to the auto shops and every one of them would remark "I've never worked on a Saturn before". When I traded the Saturn for the Jeep, I thought this issue would be over, but as fate would have it, one person was installing a trailer hitch on my Jeep and remarked "I've never worked on a Jeep before". You know, not like they haven't been making them for the last 60 years or so.
Focus: When you move to a new area, how do you decide what auto place to take your car to for maintenance more complicated than a simple oil change or tire rotation? Word of Mouth? Website Reviews? Just take it to the dealer?

RIP 1997 Saturn SL2. Killed at the hands of mechanics in Daleville, Alabama after 140,000 miles :(